What is SecondAppraisal?
SecondAppraisal appraises vehicles declared a total loss. An insurance company's first offer on a totaled vehicle can be lower than its true market value. We research comparable vehicles, review your car's condition from your photos, when you have them, and build a defensible valuation report. We are independent of every insurance company, and we are not affiliated with, endorsed by, or acting on behalf of any insurer. When you appoint us, we are your appraiser under the policy. The two appraisers decide the amount of loss on the evidence, and we keep you informed and consult you before an umpire is engaged. We're also happy to walk you through how it all works before you commit to anything, and that first conversation carries no obligation.
What do I need to get started, and can I start without the valuation report?
You'll need your insurance company's market valuation report (a PDF from providers like CCC ONE, Mitchell WorkCenter, or Audatex Autosource), your insurance information (company name, claim number, and adjuster contact if you have it), and basic details about your vehicle. You don't need all of it up front, though — during intake you can skip the report upload and create your consultation right away, then add the report later from your dashboard whenever it's ready.
Do I need an appraiser near me?
No. Our work is valuation research, built from your insurer's valuation report, your vehicle details and comparable listings from your own market, and, as your appraiser under your policy's appraisal clause, determining the amount of loss with your insurer's appraiser. There's no office visit: we work with you by phone, text, and online. We serve drivers in 39+ states; if your state requires a license we don't hold, we'll tell you in the free consultation, before you pay anything.
How does the process work, from start to finish?
It starts with a simple intake: upload your insurer's market valuation report, provide your insurance details, and create an account. From there, our team analyzes the report and researches comparable vehicles in your area under the direction of our appraiser, Jonathon A. Thomas, who forms the opinion of value, and we ask you to appoint us as your appraiser under the appraisal clause of your policy, if it has one. The insurance company then appoints its own appraiser, and our appraiser determines the amount of loss with that appraiser, including at the appraisal conference. Once the two agree on a new actual cash value, an appraisal award letter is sent to you and your carrier as the updated value for your settlement. After they receive it, request an updated total-loss settlement breakdown so you can confirm how the new value — plus taxes and fees, minus any deductible — produces your final payout. You can track every step from your dashboard, and we provide everything in writing.
How do I communicate with SecondAppraisal during my consultation?
Your consultation dashboard includes a built-in messaging system where you can send and receive messages from our team. You'll also find a Communications page that shows all your emails, texts, and notifications in one place. We'll notify you whenever there's an update. Plus you can always message or call Jane, our AI assistant, at any time. She calls you only if you ask or say yes to her.
Where does my vehicle need to be, and what about an insurer field inspector?
Wherever it currently is — a body shop, a salvage yard, or your home all work fine. Our appraisal is based on documentation, photos, and comparable-market research, not a single in-person inspection, so the vehicle's location doesn't hold things up; just tell us where it is and whether access is limited. It's also routine for the insurer to send a third-party field inspector to photograph the vehicle and confirm its condition — that's harmless, it doesn't change your right to dispute the valuation, and it doesn't interfere with our work. One thing about the photos themselves: the only place we can pull photos for you automatically is a Copart or IAAI salvage auction, and only when you can give us the lot or stock number. If your vehicle is at a body shop, a tow yard, or your home, we can't retrieve photos from there — so the best move is to take the photos yourself, or have whoever can reach the vehicle (including the shop) take them, and upload them to your dashboard. Aim for the full set of about 21 angles; whatever you can get is better than nothing, and good photos are a big part of getting your valuation right.
What does it cost, when does the fee apply, and what is the pre-authorization?
Your appraisal consultation is free: we review your situation and tell you whether it's worth pursuing. The Appointed Appraiser Service is $495. It includes the Appraisal Research, our appointment as your appraiser under the appraisal clause of your policy, if it has one, determining the amount of loss with your insurer's appraiser, and the appraisal award letter. There's no upfront payment. After we review your consultation and agree to take it on, we place a pre-authorization on your card for the fee — a hold that confirms the card and reserves the amount, not a charge. You're billed once your consultation is complete. Appraisal Research is $199: a written research report only. It doesn't appoint us as your appraiser. We offer it on its own in your consultation, when a research report is what you need. We accept common payment methods; if a card doesn't go through we'll let you know so you can update it, and we can still send your documents in writing in the meantime.
Watch the walkthrough: https://youtu.be/j-HxFx_khyA
How much more will I get?
Across our finished consultations, the average increase over the insurer's first offer was $3,648, before our fee. From customers across our services whose consultations finished with a settlement on file; past results, not a promise or prediction, and not an average across all total losses. Even when the headline numbers look like a tie, the real math can favor you, because when the insurer pays a higher vehicle value the sales tax and licensing they pay on top scale up with it. In real examples, a Honda Civic whose offer matched our appraisal still left the owner about $1,440 more in the bank, and an appraisal that came in $100 below the offer still netted $661 more once tax and licensing leverage were applied. It's always worth running the real math.
Watch the walkthrough: https://youtu.be/VdXXuLJ8IkQ
When does the card pre-authorization hold release if I'm not charged?
The pre-authorization is a hold, not a charge — it confirms the card and reserves our $495 Appointed Appraiser Service fee, and you're only actually billed once your consultation is complete and the fee is owed. If your consultation ends without a charge, we release the hold on our side, and released holds typically clear from your account within a few business days. Even if a hold is never captured or released explicitly, card networks drop uncaptured authorizations automatically — usually in about 7 days, though the exact timing depends on your bank. If a hold seems stuck longer than that, contact support@secondappraisal.com and we'll sort it out.
What if the result doesn't cover your fee?
Our Appointed Appraiser Service fee is a flat fee, shown on our pricing page. That's why the Free Appraisal Consultation comes first: we won't recommend our service unless we believe we can help you do better than your insurance company's offer, and we always take our fee into account. If your membership or a lender's program includes our fee, you don't pay it.
What is Total Loss Appraisal Support, and how do I use it if my car is totaled?
Total Loss Appraisal Support is a per-vehicle membership, paid monthly or yearly for each car you register by VIN; the current membership fee, and what paying yearly saves, is always on secondappraisal.com/membership. Each membership year it includes our Appointed Appraiser Service for that car, with the Appraisal Research — our regular $495 service — if it's declared a total loss. Losses on or after your eligible-from date, 30 days after your car is registered, are included. If a lender or GAP administrator arranged your membership, losses on or after the day the membership starts are included. It's a membership, not insurance: we never pay claims or guarantee a result. Your insurance company pays your settlement; we do the research and serve as your appraiser. If a registered car is totaled, sign in, open your Garage Hub, and choose "Start my member consultation" — we fill in the vehicle for you. On the payment step your membership is applied automatically by VIN, so there's nothing to pay, and if we don't have your date of loss yet we'll ask for it first. You can add another car, update your card, see invoices, or cancel at the end of the billing period from your Garage Hub.
How do I upload my insurance's valuation report, and why does it matter?
From your dashboard, open the upload task and add the PDF your insurer sent (often from CCC ONE, Mitchell, or Audatex). This report is the starting point for everything we do — it shows exactly which comparable vehicles and condition adjustments the insurer used, so we can find where they undervalued your car. If the in-browser upload gives you trouble, you can also email the file to support@secondappraisal.com and we'll attach it for you.
How do I send the appraiser-authorization, add my adjuster details, and what if the adjuster won't cooperate?
Your dashboard provides a ready-to-send appraiser-authorization that tells your insurer you've appointed us as your appraiser under your policy's appraisal clause. You send it yourself (or forward it to your adjuster), and it's usually the single most important step to move your consultation forward: it asks your insurer for its appraiser's name and contact details, and to keep copying you. First, add your insurance company, claim number, and adjuster's name and contact info on your dashboard so the authorization reaches the right people; the adjuster's email in particular lets it reach them directly. If your adjuster won't give you a direct email, try pressing 0 while on the phone or asking to escalate to a supervisor, or use the carrier's document-upload portal — we make it easy to copy and paste the exact message to upload. As a last resort you can mail a printed letter. Your insurance claim stays between you and your insurance company. If you appoint us as your appraiser under the appraisal clause of your policy, if it has one, we work with the insurer's appraiser on the amount of loss, not with your adjuster on your claim. This is general information, not legal advice.
How do I take and upload my vehicle photos?
From your dashboard you can upload photos directly in your browser, or we can text or email you a photo-upload link so you can shoot and submit from your phone. Good photos can be worth thousands of dollars in the appraisal, so it's worth taking the full set — about 21 photos — carefully. General tips: shoot in daylight, park on level ground if you safely can, get the whole vehicle in each exterior frame, and keep your hands steady so the images are sharp. Exterior (8 shots): a three-quarter angle from each corner (front-left, rear-left, rear-right, front-right), a full side view of each side, a straight-on rear, and a straight-on front with the bumper, grille, and headlights in frame. Under the hood: open it and photograph the engine bay from the front of the car. Doors: for each door (driver, front passenger, and the rears if present), take two shots — one at a 45° angle into the opening toward the front, and one straight into the cabin. Interior and odometer: open the trunk or hatch and shoot inside, photograph the odometer so the mileage is legible, and capture two full-cabin views — one from the front passenger seat looking back, one from the rear looking forward. If your car is at a Copart or IAAI salvage auction and you can give us the lot or stock number, we can often pull the photos directly — but anywhere else (a body shop, tow yard, or your home), you'll need to take and upload them yourself. Once you've taken the full set, send them in and your appraiser will use them to support your vehicle's full value.
Watch the walkthrough: https://youtu.be/eKeUmf1sMNo
Which receipts and recent maintenance add value, and how do I upload them?
Recent major work can add value the insurer's report missed, because that report may give little or no credit for what you've put into the car. Upload the receipts to your dashboard and we'll use them as evidence in the appraisal. What to send: major mechanical work (engine or transmission work, head gaskets, timing belts, suspension rebuilds, comprehensive brakes), new tires, and aftermarket additions (wheels, audio, lift kits, towing packages, ceramic coatings, paint protection film, wraps, tint, performance parts, premium leather, roof racks, lighting, installed dash cams). A good rule of thumb: if it's bolted, stitched, sprayed, or wired in, lasts at least a year, and cost more than a couple hundred dollars, we want to see it — ideally as a dated receipt or invoice. What to skip: consumables you replace more than once a year — oil changes, wiper blades, air filters, washer fluid, brake pads alone, light bulbs. How much it's worth: we value each item at the time of loss using professional judgment rather than a flat rule. Newer items can be credited at more of their cost, while older items depreciate over their realistic useful life — tires depreciate quickly, whereas a properly remanufactured transmission holds value much longer. If you don't have a receipt, the shop or retailer can usually look it up and email it.
Watch the walkthrough: https://youtu.be/lI7fgYjjTeY
How do I find my Copart or IAAI lot number (stock number)?
After a total loss, the insurance company usually tows your vehicle to a salvage yard run by either Copart or IAAI and parks it under a reference number — Copart calls it a lot number, IAAI calls it a stock number. You typically won't have that number yourself, but your insurance company does: call or message your adjuster and ask for the Copart lot number or IAAI stock number where your vehicle is being stored. Once you have it, pass it along to us — with that number we can usually pull the auction's photos of your vehicle automatically, so you don't have to take the 21 photos yourself. If your vehicle hasn't been towed to a Copart or IAAI yard (it's still at a body shop, a tow yard, or your home), there's no lot number to find — in that case, taking and uploading the photos yourself is the way to go.
How do you determine my vehicle's value?
Real, local market comparables drive value far more than a single book figure. We start from your insurer's market valuation report and run an NADA (J.D. Power) value as a sanity check, but those book tools don't always reflect what a comparable vehicle actually sells for in your area. So we pull real, recent comparable listings near you — matching trim, mileage, and options — and document condition and equipment differences to build an actual cash value we can defend in the appraisal. We also go and get the manufacturer's original Monroney label to verify the features on your vehicle and compare them to comparables. The range we show you runs from our most conservative comparable up to the average of the comparables we selected (plus any add-ons like recent maintenance): the low end is intentionally cautious, and the high end is the average market value we believe we can support. We generally won't recommend moving forward unless we see a strong chance of creating meaningful additional value, and we always pursue the highest fair value the evidence supports.
What's the difference between ACV and my total settlement, and why is the headline number misleading?
ACV (actual cash value) is the insurer's figure for what your vehicle itself is worth — and it's not the same as your total settlement. In most states the insurer owes you the ACV plus the sales tax and title/registration fees you'd pay to replace the vehicle, added on top, then minus your deductible when it applies. So a headline settlement figure can be misleading: a $16,500 offer might actually break down to roughly $15,130 in vehicle value, about $1,120 in tax, $250 in title and licensing, and a $500 deductible — meaning a big chunk is earmarked for taxes and DMV fees you'll owe when you replace the car. That's also why our appraisal focuses on ACV: it's the figure that drives everything else. The exact tax-and-fee rules vary by state and policy, so we confirm what applies to your claim.
Can I keep my totaled vehicle, and is the salvage buyback price fixed?
Usually yes. If you want to keep your totaled vehicle, the insurer deducts the salvage (buyback) value from your settlement and you retain the car with a salvage title. That buyback amount isn't fixed — as a rough rule of thumb it often lands around 20 cents on the dollar of the vehicle's value, so if a quote looks high it's worth pushing back or asking for the carrier's salvage source. Getting the figure right matters, because an inflated salvage value quietly lowers your net payout. Tell us if you're considering keeping the vehicle and we'll sanity-check the number against the actual cash value and factor it into the appraisal so you're not overpaying to retain your car.
How long does the whole process — and the appraisal clause — take?
Our standard turnaround for the appraisal research is 24 hours from the time you submit your insurance company's report and vehicle details. From there it depends on how responsive your insurer is: it can take up to a few weeks, but it usually resolves in just a few days. Disputed consultations can run 30–60 days — that's roughly the worst case, the most an insurer can drag it out before violating their own clause. Once you appoint us under the appraisal clause, determining the amount of loss with the other appraiser follows the same shape — it can take up to a few weeks but usually resolves in a few days. How long the appraisal takes depends on the insurance company's appointed appraiser and, if one is needed, the umpire. We push to keep things on the faster end, and your dashboard tracks progress through every phase.
Why didn't my value change after my call?
Your value isn't updated live during the call. After we talk, our appraiser, Jonathon A. Thomas, reviews your consultation and finalizes the valuation. Nothing is lost from your call; the number on your dashboard updates once that review is complete, and we'll email you the moment your report is ready.
What is the appraisal clause (right to appraisal)?
Most US auto insurance policies include an appraisal clause — a built-in way to settle a disagreement over how much your loss is worth. Not every policy has an appraisal clause. Your policy's own wording says whether yours does, and your insurer can confirm it. Under most clauses, if you and your insurer can't agree on the vehicle's value, either side can demand an appraisal, and each side hires and pays for its own appraiser. If the two appraisers can't agree, under most clauses a neutral umpire decides. In the rare event that an umpire is needed, there will be an additional cost. We'll check with you if it looks like that's needed. A decision agreed to by two of the three sets the amount, as your policy's clause provides. You don't have to approve it separately, but we keep you in the loop along the way, and that amount settles value only (not fault or coverage). Your policy states its own terms. For a legal question about your own situation, a licensed attorney can help. This is general information, not legal advice.
How do I invoke the appraisal clause, and how does it work?
Most clauses call for a written demand, and an email to your claim representative is the usual way to send one; your policy states its own terms. On your dashboard, we prepare the appointment letter for you to review, change if you wish, and send. You can also send a letter of your own. If you don't hear back in a few days, you can follow up with a certified letter. Many policies give the insurer a set period, often 20 days, to name its appraiser; your policy states its own. As your appraiser, we pull the comparable sales, document your vehicle's condition, and work directly with the insurer's appraiser to determine the amount of loss — about 95% of the time the two professionals reach a number on their own, with no judge, jury, or lawyers involved, and only if they can't does a neutral umpire break the tie. Appraisal procedures and policy language vary by state. For a legal question about your own situation, a licensed attorney can help. This is general information, not legal advice.
Watch the walkthrough: https://youtu.be/j-HxFx_khyA
Should I file through my own insurance or the at-fault driver's?
Which path you choose matters. Filing through the at-fault driver's insurer is a claim under their policy, so your own policy's appraisal clause doesn't apply to it. Filing through your own insurance is a claim under your own policy, so its appraisal clause, if it has one, applies. In some states, we can serve as your appraiser only under your own policy or if the other driver's insurer agrees; your dashboard shows what applies in yours. When the other driver was at fault, you typically pay your deductible up front and your insurer seeks it back from theirs (the rates-and-deductible answer explains how and when). This is general information, not legal advice — rules vary by state and insurer, so a quick check with your own carrier is always worth it. The choice is yours.
Watch the walkthrough: https://youtu.be/Pw6cFeZ2dkM
Will filing or an appraisal raise my rates, and do I get my deductible back?
Two common worries, and the news is mostly good when you're not at fault. Rates: surcharges are generally for accidents you cause, not the ones you don't, so a clearly not-at-fault claim usually shouldn't move your premium — and several states (including California, Colorado and Louisiana) prohibit raising your rate for a not-at-fault accident. Disputing the value of an already-filed claim, through an appraisal or otherwise, doesn't by itself raise rates either. Deductible: if you file through your own insurer you typically pay it up front, but you generally don't end up paying it when the other driver was at fault — your carrier pursues the at-fault insurer through subrogation and, in many states, must return that money to you before keeping anything. It can take a few weeks to come back, and if you were partly at fault you'll get your share rather than the full amount. If you file directly through the at-fault carrier, a deductible usually doesn't apply at all. Rules vary by carrier and state, so confirm the specifics with your insurer. Your policy states its own terms. This is general information, not legal advice.
Watch the walkthrough: https://youtu.be/Pw6cFeZ2dkM
What does an umpire cost, and how often is one actually needed?
Only when the two appraisers can't agree. In an appraisal, they work to determine the amount of loss first, and a neutral umpire comes in only to break a tie. If an umpire is needed, each side pays its share of the umpire's fee as your policy sets out, and we bill yours at exactly what the umpire charges. Umpire procedures vary a little by state and policy, so we'll walk you through the specifics if your consultation ever gets that far.
Should I sign up with SecondAppraisal first, or invoke the appraisal clause first?
You can sign up first; invoking, if you choose to, comes later. Here's how the order works: (1) Upload your insurer's market valuation report and your vehicle details — this part is free. (2) Our team prepares your free appraisal consultation under the direction of our appraiser, Jonathon A. Thomas, who forms the opinion of value; it shows what our review finds about your vehicle's value and your insurer's offer. (3) If the review supports it, you decide whether to invoke the appraisal clause of your policy, if it has one, and appoint us as your appraiser; we prepare the appointment letter for you to review, change if you wish, and send. Many policies set time limits once the clause is invoked; your policy states its own terms, and whether and when to invoke is your decision. If you've already invoked on your own, don't worry — we can still step in as your appraiser; just sign up and let us know where things stand.
Who handles my consultation, and what are their qualifications?
Jonathon A. Thomas forms every opinion of value on every SecondAppraisal consultation. Our staff and contracted team collect documents and vehicle listings under his direction. He is our Chief Operating Officer. He brings over 13 years of total-loss, liability, and damages experience, and holds the CPCU and AIDA professional designations and a Master of Science in Finance. Jonathon A. Thomas holds motor vehicle damage appraiser licenses in Connecticut, North Carolina and South Carolina, and an Oregon Vehicle Appraiser Certificate. SecondAppraisal Inc holds a Connecticut motor vehicle damage appraiser license (MVPD Appraiser, #3004387010). He's joined by CEO Ken Davis, who applies decades of software and technology experience to modernize how owners navigate total-loss claims.
Do you handle classic, specialty, or heavily customized vehicles?
Those fall outside our usual wheelhouse. Standard total-loss appraisals on regular, mainstream-market vehicles are where we deliver the most value. For a classic, exotic, or heavily customized vehicle, a specialty appraiser is usually a better fit, and we're happy to point you in that direction. If you're not sure whether your vehicle counts as standard-market, just give us a quick description and we'll let you know.
Is SecondAppraisal legitimate? How do I verify you?
Completely fair question — here's what you can verify yourself. Jonathon A. Thomas forms every opinion of value on every SecondAppraisal consultation. Our staff and contracted team collect documents and vehicle listings under his direction. He holds the CPCU and AIDA professional designations. You can read our Google reviews from customers we've helped — ask Jane to text or email you the link, or search "SecondAppraisal Inc" on Google Maps. Everything happens inside your secure dashboard where you can see your documents, messages, and progress at any time. And two things we will never do: we never ask for payment information over the phone (card pre-authorization happens only through a secure link in your dashboard), and you're never charged our flat $495 fee until after we deliver. If you'd rather hear it from a person, a member of our team is happy to message or call you.
Is my information secure?
Yes. We use secure authentication (Google Sign-In, Apple Sign-In, and email or phone one-time passwords), transmit all data over encrypted connections, and follow industry best practices for protecting your personal and claim information.
How do I contact support?
Email support@secondappraisal.com or text (385) 218-6712. During your consultation, the dashboard messaging system is the fastest way to reach our team.
What are your hours, and do you speak Spanish?
Real people are here 7 a.m.–7 p.m. Mountain, 7 days a week, and se habla español. Outside those hours, Jane, our AI assistant, can help in 97 languages, and we follow up when we're back.
Can you handle my whole claim?
No. Your insurance claim stays between you and your insurance company. When you appoint us, we are your appraiser under the policy. The two appraisers decide the amount of loss on the evidence, and we keep you informed and consult you before an umpire is engaged. If you want help with the rest of your insurance claim, an attorney can help, and in many states a licensed public adjuster can too. We don't name or recommend anyone.